Timeline of Sex Education Reform

  in Volusia County Public Schools

 

May 2008 - May 2009

last updated: June 30, 2010

Contact: Lynn Koller

Ormond Beach, Florida

Lynn@CosmicScribbler.com

www.CosmicScribbler.com

Introduction


Volusia County Public School officials have made some significant changes from the original "abstinence-only-until-marriage" program administered in 7th through 12th grades from 2000 through 2008 by a veiled religious organization, Deltona-based Pure Energy. This organization used federal funding received for abstinence-only education in public schools to fund the Central Florida Pregnancy Center, which advocates against women's reproductive rights, and used a curriculum containing false information and lacking a factual foundation that promoted a homophobic, at least mildly misogynistic message to students. The material contains false information about contraception and, frankly, is just creepy.

However, Volusia County is still a long way from a comprehensive sex education program based on facts over ideology that addresses the spectrum of gender and sexuality, will help our students make healthy choices, and will help prevent unplanned pregnancies and the transmission of STDs, along with providing students with a genuine understanding of human sexuality as a driving force of human behavior.

If you are interested in supporting sex education reform in Volusia County Public Schools, please contact me. (Your personal information will not be shared without your permission.)

In the News


In the latest
example of powerful political abstinence-only advocates tripping over their genitalia, the married Republican Mark Souder resigned from Congress on May 18, 2010, because he was caught having sex with one of his aides - who he shot a pro-abstinence video with (ouchy).

According to Mike Larsen on the Huffington Post: "Souder made a name for himself as an evangelical Christian who embraces family values such as fighting AIDS prevention programs that include information on safe sex. So, I find it wonderfully ironic that a man who preached abstinence-only for AIDS prevention was brought down by his inability to abstain from his aide."

Of course, Souder is no teenager, and he made a healthy sexual choice, according to abstinence-only dogma: You should never, ever have sex before marriage. Souder has been married to his wife for 36 years. (It just wasn't his wife who he was having sex with.)

I'm in no position to cast stones or judge the inside of anyone's marriage or their sexual choices within the context of that marriage, unless they're in a position of power and their choices reflect that they are hypocritically pushing an untenable, misguided agenda onto my children and community.

Timeline

*I wrote

May 5-June 6, 2008* Select email to and from Volusia County Public School administrators and School Board members (and me). These are just a few early communications among hundreds of emails sent and received on this issue.

A comment from a Deltona High School teacher illustrative of the perspective of some advocates of abstinence-only curricula with regard to gay and lesbian students. She states:
"I have had students of many religious backgrounds in my classes over the last several years as well as students who I 'know' have different sexual orientation, but they have NEVER felt belittled, discriminated, or targeted by the information or activities presented! It is probably more of a 'insecurity' of themself and not a fault of the presentation!" (See link for full email.)

May 22, 2008*

An editorial published in the Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Abstinence-only classes in local schools forfeit sex education to religious sermon", that instigated the issue. Flagler County was reportedly to sign a letter of intent that day Pure Energy, but, because of the controversies raised in the editorial, that did not occur.

May 30, 2008

A rebuttal (editorial) written by Jessica Errico of Pure Energy/Central Florida Pregnancy Center (this "pregnancy center" is "ministry to the hearts of women" that offers "healing for those who have been wounded by a past abortion experience"), published in The Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Critics of abstinence-only program off-base." Here's my response.

June 2-4, 2008*

Three emails written to the principal at Pine Trail Elementary School and Pine Trail parents objecting to the 5th grade girls throughout Volusia County being instructed to take virginity-until-marriage vows after a one-hour talk on puberty. The practice was reportedly eliminated within two days of the initial email.

June 10, 2008

School Board minutes. Another parent and I addressed the Volusia County School Board, advocating replacing the current abstinence-only curriculum with a comprehensive sex education program. Review the minutes here. (No discussion details are provided.)

July 17, 2008

A news article by Denise-Marie Balona of The Orlando Sentinel, "Volusia County urged to drop abstinence, teach safe sex."

July 18, 2008

A news article by Mark Harper of The Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Volusia schools' abstinence-only sex-ed program challenged."

July 25, 2008*

An editorial published in the Hometown News, "School abstinence program does not protect children", discussing the issue and three-person panel consisting of representatives from Planned Parenthood and the ACLU (and me) at the Unitarian Church in Ormond Beach.

September 5, 2008

A news article by Linda Trimble of The Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Abstinence-only sex ed suspended while under review."

September 17, 2008*

A School Health Advisory Committee (SHAC) report proposing that we adopt a comprehensive sex education program based on scientifically verifiable information for Volusia County schools.

October 16, 2008

A news article by Linda Trimble of The Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Opinions vary widely on the sex education review committee."

November 16, 2008

A news article by Linda Trimble of The Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Volusia schools to consider expanding sex education."

November 21, 2008*

A minority report written for SHAC, objecting to the conclusions reached by the committee.

November 28, 2008*

An editorial published in the Daytona Beach News-Journal, "What Schools Should Say About Sex", about the outcome of the SHAC findings.

February 22, 2009

A news article by Linda Trimble of The Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Volusia to expand sex ed curriculum."

February 25, 2009

A news article by Linda Trimble of The Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Expanded sex ed to begin in eighth grade."

February 28, 2009

An editorial by The Daytona Beach News-Journal, "Sex ed beyond abstinence: School boards would do well to level with students."

April 2, 2009

A news article by Pat Heffield of West Volusia Beacon, "Volusia County Schools to teach birth control, starting this spring."
May 1, 2009* Select email to and from Volusia County Public School administrators (and me) about the Changes Program sponsored by Proctor and Gamble for all 5th grade students. Up until that time, in some Volusia schools, boys were educated on puberty and body changes for both genders, while the girls were taught only about their own gender. (It seemed absurd.) A local pediatrician involved in the program for the boys said that educating the students only about their own gender does not offer the context necessary for the information to fully make sense to the students. In addition to the obvious problems with this scenario, such a disparity seems to send a clear message to the girls that they are not worthy or capable of handling the same level of information as boys of their age.

The policy was then changed and elementary school principals advised that both male and female students will view the co-ed material "due to an increase of pregnancy in our middle schools and even our elementary schools" (per a letter from Amy Hall, District Counseling Specialist).

return to: www.CosmicScribbler.com